SkyKing TraineeTrainee
Joined: Dec 21, 2003Posts: 3
Asked

If one decides to use a joystick.....which one works best with FS 2004? 🙄

sk

19 Answers

Latest answer ↓
Fly Away Simulation (Flyaway) Site AdminSite Admin
Joined: Jun 28, 2003Posts: 1300Location: UK
Answered

I would say that teh Sidewinder range from Microsoft is probably most popular, and very reliable. There are many to choose from. Saitek also make some great joysticks - www.saitek.com

mrkonk First OfficerFirst Officer
Joined: Jan 16, 2005Posts: 109Location: Oregon
Answered

I like saitex cyborg graphite love it. I have never had a problem with it

mrkonk First OfficerFirst Officer
Joined: Jan 16, 2005Posts: 109Location: Oregon
Answered

I mean saitek not saitex sorry

Skymuncher TraineeTrainee
Joined: Mar 20, 2005Posts: 85Location: Switzerland
Answered

The Saitek x52 HOTAS is just awesome. But if you want the top for civilian simulation: CH Flight Sim Yoke USB and Pro Pedals USB.
Microsoft Sidewinder FF2 is also a good pick

John Hodges (originalgrunge) CaptainCaptain
Joined: Feb 29, 2004Posts: 726Location: New York City
Answered

I'll chime in and reccomend the Microsoft Force Feedback 2 as well. It gives you a great feel for what your aircraft can and can't do as the forces give your arm a good workout. I'm sure though that after all this time there are better force feedback's out there, but for a good value this one works.

Matthew Shope (mypilot) Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Nov 26, 2004Posts: 1695Location: Long Beach, California KLGB/KTOA
Answered

I doubt if SkyKing will look back at this post. His last post was on Jan. 7, 2004. 😕

I recommend Logitch Force Feedback 3d pro.

Sam Intel Guest
Answered

I have the CH products yoke and rudder pedals. I also have the Logitech Extreme 3D Pro, it works great! 😀 I have never tried the Sidewinder from Microsoft so I don't know how good it is.

Spirit 234 Guest
Answered

Please do reply, as your wisdom is great for guys like me coming new to the forum.

I just ordered the ssff2 (sidewinder force feedbak 2)

after a long stint with the thrustmaster afterburner 2 (hotas)

and an abortive trive with a new logitec stick (extreme 3d)

kianok First OfficerFirst Officer
Joined: Jan 02, 2006Posts: 349Location: Leeds, UK - EGNM
Answered

Can't go wrong with the Sidewinder in my view 😉

CRJCapt Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Sep 12, 2005Posts: 3722Location: Ohio,USA
Answered

I use the CH Flight Sim Yoke, CH Throttle Quadrant and CH Pedals. I also have a Logitech Extreme 3D Pro for flying Aerobatics and Helicopters. 🙂

hms_endeavour Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Nov 03, 2004Posts: 1351Location: In the sky
Answered

I have the portable Saitek st90,and it good and small but the button throttle is annoying!Tommorow i'm getting my new Saitek X52!!!!Just awesome!!!!!!

Solotwo Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Jan 26, 2006Posts: 1186Location: Milwaukee, WI
Answered

I love my X52 to death, can't go wrong.

Michael_H First OfficerFirst Officer
Joined: Mar 18, 2004Posts: 382Location: B.C. Canada
Answered

I also use a Microsoft Sidewinder, not really fancy but works very well.

Guest
Answered

So if you had to pick between the CH Yoke and the x52, which one?

CRJCapt Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Sep 12, 2005Posts: 3722Location: Ohio,USA
Answered

I would chose the CH Yoke even though they are both excellent. The Yoke is more authentic for most aircraft have a control wheel (I know Airbus has a stick). The Pilot in command normally flies with the left hand and operates the throttle or power levers with the right. The X52 won't allow this configuration at least not without losing reach of some of the switches on the throttle.

If you fly combat, aerobatics or other stick aircraft, the X52 is better. In single seat or tandem seat aircraft, where the pilot flies with the stick in the right hand, the X52 would be more authentic. The multitude of buttons and switches would be really handy for combat flying.

For most civil aircraft flying, the CH Yoke.

Just buy both! 🙂

beerbadger First OfficerFirst Officer
Joined: Nov 25, 2005Posts: 346
Answered

sorry but mr konk what aircraft is that in your avatar?

Guest
Answered

So If I am understanding correctly. Since the planes I want to fly are mainly large jets I would be best with the Yoke?

*by the time I finally pick one, something new will come out 😉 *

Canyon (NoWorries) First OfficerFirst Officer
Joined: Jul 22, 2005Posts: 351
Answered

beerbadger wrote:

sorry but mr konk what aircraft is that in your avatar?

That's gotta be a 787...based on the colors and its obviously a release. I don't think Boeings were painted in the Dreamliner colors when the 757/767 and the 777 were released.

As for the question at hand, I use a Sidewinder Forcedeally...I have all of the forcefeedback turned off because it is never realistic to what the plane is doing. The only thing I really don't like about it is that it has no autocenter feature on MSFS, however, on most other flight sims, it is magneticaly centered, which is way cool.

For MSFS, my major recommendations are a thottle, rudder, and self-centering...

CRJCapt Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Sep 12, 2005Posts: 3722Location: Ohio,USA
Answered

To Guest above: In my opinion, yes.

Know a better answer?

Add what worked for you. Every answer helps the next simmer who searches for this.

Ask Fly Away · AI assistant

Still stuck on this question?

Ask Fly Away, our AI flight sim & aviation assistant, for an instant answer to this exact question — or ask the community below.