Alex (Fire_Emblem_Master) Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Oct 19, 2003Posts: 2325Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Asked

Hey guys. I've got a dispute going on with a buddy of mine. My friend claims that if someone got pissed at him, and wrote him an email telling him why they're all pissed off and how they never want to see them again, he can file charges and prosecute.

I said that if the person did not threaten him in any way, no legal action can be taken.

Which is right?

We live in Michigan, USA

12 Answers

Latest answer ↓
WarHawk42 CaptainCaptain
Joined: Jun 14, 2004Posts: 791
Answered

I would say you are right, as long as there is no threat. Since the email was sent to the person they were angry at there could be no libel for slander of defamation either, it is a private conversation.

I don't see any kind of legal action that could be taken.

Alex (Fire_Emblem_Master) Asker Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Oct 19, 2003Posts: 2325Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Answered

Score one for FEM (This actually did happen about 4 weeks ago...this kid hated him...blah blah blah.)

jarred_01 CaptainCaptain
Joined: Aug 29, 2005Posts: 938Location: Hamilton, New Zealand (NZHN)
Answered

I agree with Warhawk, I would highly doubt they can do anything as they were not threatened.

CrashGordon Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Jun 20, 2005Posts: 3821
Answered

If it were a criminal offense to tell someone you don't like them and never want to see them, "Dear John" letters would get the writer jail time. If there is no threat., there is no crime.

About the only exception I can think of is if you keep sending letters or emails suggesting gruesome things, a charge of unlawful harrassment might be in order.

Matthew Shope (mypilot) Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Nov 26, 2004Posts: 1695Location: Long Beach, California KLGB/KTOA
Answered

In California, I think this is correct if someone is purposely falsely slandered in public that they could be seued/sewed (whatever the spelling of it is :lol🙂

WarHawk42 CaptainCaptain
Joined: Jun 14, 2004Posts: 791
Answered

mypilot wrote:

In California, I think this is correct if someone is purposely falsely slandered in public that they could be seued/sewed (whatever the spelling of it is :lol🙂

In this case the email is a private communication, no slander involved since it isn't made public by the sender.

CrashGordon Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Jun 20, 2005Posts: 3821
Answered

That is true in most places. One can be sued for slander or libel.

However, if I send some one a letter that says, "I hate you because you have bad breath, body odor and gas. I don't want you anywhere near me", I can't be sued. Since I am telling the person directly and no one else, no defamation has legally occured.

Insight Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Feb 17, 2005Posts: 1155Location: UK, South East
Answered

you are of course forgetting we are talking about the US of A here...

a place where a man had an itch in his nostril, put a drill in it and turned it on to scratch the itch - subsequently tore his nose off and then went about sueing the manufacturer for not providing a warning sticker saying "do not put in nose and switch on"

AND where a woman sued after burning her self with a cup of coffee she just bought because it didn't say "hot" on the side...

anything could happen people 😀

in fact, i will probably get sued for writing this post 😀

WarHawk42 CaptainCaptain
Joined: Jun 14, 2004Posts: 791
Answered

We have to keep all those lawyers working. 🙂

We do have the highest number of lawyers per capita in the world and it's silly things like you pointed out that keep them in business.

CrashGordon Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Jun 20, 2005Posts: 3821
Answered

You can sue for any reason. Even a ridiculous reason. Winning is a different story.

Jonathan (99jolegg) Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Jun 26, 2004Posts: 4112Location: UK
Answered

Insight wrote:

you are of course forgetting we are talking about the US of A here...

a place where a man had an itch in his nostril, put a drill in it and turned it on to scratch the itch - subsequently tore his nose off and then went about sueing the manufacturer for not providing a warning sticker saying "do not put in nose and switch on"

AND where a woman sued after burning her self with a cup of coffee she just bought because it didn't say "hot" on the side...

anything could happen people 😀

in fact, i will probably get sued for writing this post 😀

....and the woman who put her dog in the mircowave when it came in from the rain to dry him quickly. He died, she sued the microwave manufacturer and won 🙄

Greekman72 Chief CaptainChief Captain
Joined: Jun 15, 2005Posts: 5418Location: Hellas
Answered

....and the woman who put her dog in the mircowave when it came in from the rain to dry him quickly. He died, she sued the microwave manufacturer and won

ROFL ROFL ROFL

This is the price of ''Political Correct''.... 😉

Know a better answer?

Add what worked for you. Every answer helps the next simmer who searches for this.

Ask Fly Away · AI assistant

Still stuck on this question?

Ask Fly Away, our AI flight sim & aviation assistant, for an instant answer to this exact question — or ask the community below.